This post is by Larry Osborne, he has some great insights as to why the sermon based small group model is optimal for discipleship.
At North Coast Church, where I serve as senior pastor, we’ve had a long and interesting journey with small groups. We had no groups when we first started out. But after a while, I began to realize that our congregation was more of a crowd than a living, breathing community. So we launched small groups, and things began to change immediately.
For a number of years we hunted down the best curriculum available and provided it to our groups. They grew, and people’s lives did change. But when I put together a sermon series called “The Company of the Committed”—in which I wanted to paint the picture of what a committed Christian lifestyle would look like on a day-to-day basis—we experimented with our first sermon-based groups. The response was off the charts. It was so positive that we never looked back.
Over the years, I’ve noticed that tying the study guide to the sermon has several advantages over a curriculum-based model. Here are seven of the most powerful advantages.
1. They Increase the Educational Impact
A number of years ago, I heard about a study that Harvard conducted for one of the military branches. Apparently the military was sending people to different conferences and training sessions, and they wanted to maximize the educational impact of those sessions by figuring out what helps people learn—and most importantly, retain and apply—the information they receive.Â
Some of the best minds at Harvard tackled this study, and they uncovered three ways to maximize the benefit of any training experience. The first was maintaining a high sense of expectation. The study showed that if people went into a training experience with high expectations, they generally learned and retained a lot more. Obviously, this one is common sense when it comes to churches. If people are coming to your church thinking, Oh, this is going to be boring, then you can probably understand why they’re not retaining what you say.
But here’s the second ingredient. The Harvard researchers also discovered that if people took good notes during the training experience, the educational impact and the life-change upon returning home would accelerate measurably. The third key had to do with discussing the material with others. If they got together and discussed the notes—and the broader training experience as a whole—their education impact and subsequent life-change was significantly increased. .
Strangely enough, those last two things are exactly what using a sermon-based small group model forces people to do.
2. They Pull in the Marginally Interested
The second advantage of sermon-based small groups is the way they can pull in the marginally interested. All churches have marginally interested people—people who come in late on a Sunday morning and slump onto a chair in the back of the sanctuary, waiting to see if a funny story or a good joke can pull them into a higher level of interest.
But it’s a different story when a marginally interested person enters a sanctuary full of people who will be discussing the sermon later in the week with their small group. That’s because a much higher percentage of the people will be taking notes and paying close attention in order to be prepared for their small group. There’s a different feeling in the air. And so that marginally interested person—who doesn’t want to stand out—tends to sit up a bit straighter and pay more attention simply to fit in. I see it at North Coast all the time. And since everyone else seems to be taking notes, they start doing that, as well.
3. They Reach More People
Sermon-based small groups also help churches reach more people in another very simple way, and it has to do with weekly attendance. Everyone misses church at one point or another. But how often do those people come clamoring to the church office to get a tape or CD of the sermon they missed? It may happen sometimes, but not often. But what if those people attend a small group later in the week and have to discuss that sermon they missed? They will almost always listen online or come by and pick up a CD.
And when those CDs are picked up, they are often passed on to others, shared, or given away. And so the end result is that more people end up hearing the message.
4. They Sharpen the Church-Wide Focus
In most churches, everyone listens to the same message, which does create a sense of unity. But when a church uses sermon-based small groups, everyone interacts with the same message, which really sharpens the focus.
I grew up in a very different style of church. We went to church on Sunday morning and heard one subject. Then we went to Sunday school and heard another subject. Then we went back on Sunday night and heard a third subject. And then we came back for the midweek service and studied a fourth subject!
I never had a clue what series we were in or what it was all about. It was just a mishmash of subjects. At North Coast, we cover less material with sermon-based groups, but our people know what we’re covering. Our focus is sharper.
5. They Mainstream New Believers
In the small-groups world, it’s kind of an unwritten rule that you don’t put new believers in with a group of long-time Christians. The new believers get intimidated. They get swallowed up—especially by those overachievers who can pronounce all the big words and places properly. New believers often can’t figure out if it’s “Job” or “job.” So we have to keep them away from the long-time Christians and start new-believer groups instead.
But does that really make sense? Is it really the best idea to get the nursery full of little kids and then make sure no adults show up? I don’t think so. And it’s certainly not the best way to make sure people stick with the church and grow. But sermon-based groups give us another option.
I don’t watch a lot of movies, so when I come across a group of people critiquing a certain film, I generally try to stay out of their way. I get intimidated by my ignorance. But if those people are talking about a movie that I’ve actually taken the time to see, I’m in on the discussion. I stand my ground because I saw the film, and I have an opinion that’s based on my own experience. And in our culture, everyone thinks they are an expert on what they’ve experienced.
The same is true of new believers who participate in a sermon-based small group. When Larry Long-Timer begins to pronounce all of the difficult words and throw out quotes from John Calvin or Chuck Swindoll, the new believer is more likely to stand his ground and offer his own opinion, because he’s experienced the sermon himself. He’ll feel like an expert based on his own experience, even if he feels lost when it comes to the genre of the Bible.
6. They Eliminate Idiot Questions
Every small-group curriculum I have ever seen has had at least one idiot question. For instance, if we’re doing a study based on 1 Timothy, and the opening verse says, ” … from Paul to Timothy,” and then question number one in the curriculum guide is, “Who wrote 1 Timothy?” I call that an idiot question. It bores people to death. But there’s a good reason those idiot questions are in every curriculum study guide. Because without the idiot questions, you can’t set the context.
But when small groups are sermon-based, the context is set in the message. The sermon gets everyone on the same page. So group leaders are free to get right into the parallel passages and personal application.
7. They Help with Leadership Recruitment
If you’re going to lead a group Bible study on Colossians, you need a pretty good grasp on the entire book. Otherwise you’ll find yourself saying things in chapter one that don’t fit with what’s said in chapters two through four. You also need to understand the difference between a good question and a bad question. In addition, you’ll need to bring some of your own research and ideas to the study; otherwise, you’re going to be answering a lot of questions with, “I don’t know.” That’s a pretty high bar to get over.
But if you lead a sermon-based small group, all you need to be is growing spiritually, excited about God’s Word, and have the ability to draw group members together and keep them together. Unlike skilled Bible teachers, I’ve found that these kinds of people grow on trees!
In my experience with recruiting group leaders, there are not many people who can lead an inductive Bible study, but there are lots of people who can facilitate a discussion of a sermon everyone has heard. Few people can teach well, especially in our culture of mass media and heightened expectation. But God has always made sure there are enough shepherds for his flock. At North Coast, they are called small-group leaders. And when they aren’t asked to do too much, they aren’t too hard to find.
Which of these advantages is most appealing to our church and ministry?
Which of these advantages is most appealing to our church and ministry?
What weaknesses exist in our ministry that might be bolstered through sermon-based small groups?
Can we identify a couple of steps we need to take in order to start a sermon-based small groups ministry (or a sermon-based option to our current ministry)?
2 thoughts on “Why Sermon Based Small Groups?”
Our church has recently decided to adopt “Stick Church” and Sermon-based small groups as a key focal point to the church ministry. They are even organizing children’s ministry around those concepts. While I don’t have a problem with Sermon-based small groups, I am a little “disturbed” by some of the comments in the book about “hamstringing competing ministries”. Our church has decided that home bible studies that are not sermon-based aren’t really a part of the Life Group ministry, and therefore fall into the “hamstringing” group of ministries. I cannot agree with or condone that position. What was done in Sticky Church may have been what God led that pastor to do, but I think each of us is accountable to walk in the gifting and wisdom that Gods calls us to use. Do you have any comments on this? Is (what I might call “blindly”) following the book advisable, or is there room for both bible studies and SBSGs?
Carl, thanks for your comment and question.
I haven’t read Sticky Church, not sure if I would even pick up a book with a title like that… just a preference on my part but here are a few things I know.
1. Pastors often know something in the church needs to be fixed. They see the problem and do not know what to do about it. So they pray and ask for guidance. This goes on for a while until one day they pick up a book and say… “thats it, this is the answer… thank you Lord!” Then they take the book and train people with it. God does work that way.
2. I do not know the context of the “hamstringing” in the book, it may have been hurtful to read or hear from your church leaders. I am sorry if it was) I hope that was not the author’s intent… and I would thank your church leaders are not trying to hurt you either. That’s my prayer anyway.
3. We have Sunday School and small groups. In sunday school topics are covered, or you can choose what book of the Bible you would like to study. Small group studies tie directly in with the sunday sermon. We place a high value on the preaching of the word as I am sure you do too. We believe that God has a message for the church and it is so important that we need to review it and talk about it with each other sometime during the week. We do this in small groups. This is modeled after the church in Acts. (I wish I could unpack that for you but this is just a reply to your comment)
4. It is not healthy for your church to do both (Bible Studies and SBSGs). If part of your groups are sermon based and part are subject based the community is fractured. The two strategies are incompatible.
The topics, in small groups that have their own bible study, will stays within the bounds of the group and will seldom be discussed outside its membership. Mean while the sermon based group grows deeper together and have all things in common with the other groups that are following the sermon based plan. They are thinking the same sort of things, it becomes part of conversations in Walmart or at a fellowship regardless of the group they are in. It really creates a unity thats extremely deep. (I hope that made sense)
(BTW – If your church has multiple services it is even more important to go in the sermon based direction).
However, if a church decides to do a topic based approach to small groups, and the whole church is following that one strategy, that would work. I am not saying that the topical bible study approach doesn’t work. It just doesn’t work with the Sermon Based approach.
When you have two strategies in place, (Sermon Based and Topical Bible Studies) you are headed in more than one direction… and that is never good.
Carl, you know I have no skin in the game… I do not even know what church you go to. But, I love all Churches and will be praying for you and your fellowship as you go through these changes.
Grace and Peace – Phillip Brande